Everyone experiences life from their own point of view, it is difficult not to feel like the central figure in your own story when you are the one living it. But there is a difference between seeing yourself that way and expecting the world to play along. 

Kelly Reichardt’s The Mastermind follows a man who never quite understands that difference.


The Mastermind Directed by Kelly Reichardt
Josh O’Connor as James Blaine Mooney

JB Mooney (played by Josh O'Connor) is a carpenter in 1970 Massachusetts, the son of a judge with a wife, two children and a comfortable home. His life looks perfectly ordinary from the outside, but he seems restless inside it. Early on, he pockets an object from a museum and walks out. It’s a small proof to himself that he can do something beyond the life he has settled into. The robbery he plans next is the same impulse on a bigger scale. He doesn’t need the money so much as the story, in which he’s the clever one holding every thread.


Reichardt never gives him quite the film he seems to imagine himself in. Shot on 16mm by cinematographer Christopher Blauvelt, The Mastermind is full of wide, steady compositions and muted colors. JB rarely dominates the image. He shares it with ordinary rooms, furniture and the people around him, none of whom seem particularly interested in making him feel important. The film is patient, sometimes almost stubbornly so. When JB has to hide the stolen paintings, we watch him move them, carry them upstairs and struggle through the practical work of putting them away. A conventional heist film would probably find a way to make this look clever. Reichardt makes us sit with how tedious it is.


The jazz score keeps promising excitement, but it belongs to the movie JB thinks he’s in.


Alana Haim as Terri Mooney


Josh O'Connor plays him without contempt. JB has real charm that makes it possible to understand why people continue to give him chances. He has moments of competence, and he can be persuasive when he needs something. When he asks his wife, Terri (played by Alana Haim), for “a little faith” the film invites us to do the same, subsequently revealing what it costs the person who keeps giving it. 

That trust comes at a price for those around him. JB treats everyone around him as supporting cast, but he rarely seems to consider what his decisions demand of them. His circumstances make this particularly revealing. He has a home and a family, and he is not stealing because he has no other way to survive. He wants something else, though he never seems entirely sure what it is. There is a sense that he has grown accustomed to being accommodated, and that he mistakes this for being in control.


I found myself less engaged by the second half of the film. Once the heist is over, the suspense I had been waiting for largely disappears. JB spends much of what follows drifting from one mess to another, looking for money, somewhere to stay, or another person willing to help him. 

For a while, I felt detached from the energy of the first half. I kept expecting him to find a way out, or at least to do something that would make all his planning feel worthwhile. Eventually, I began to wonder whether my frustration was part of what the film was asking me to confront. 



The final stretch brings him to encounter the political unrest that has been present at the edges of the film. In Cincinnati, desperate for a way out, he steals a woman’s purse and runs into a crowd of Vietnam War protesters. Earlier, the chaos of the era had mostly reached him through the background of his comfortable life. Now, he tries to hide behind the people facing that turmoil as cover for his own actions. He has spent the film absorbed in his private ambitions, but the world outside them has never stopped moving. When the police take him away, there is no grand confrontation, his story ends without the significance he believes it should have had.


In the end, the only thing JB steals is a role he was never cast in.